Games Achievements My Kong Sign In

Comments for Sherlock Has a Clue

« Back to Sherlock Has a Clue

keneticmotion

Jul. 19, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) I LOVE this one. Clue!

+ - !

(2)

BRAINIAC326967

Jun. 11, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) The game won't load.

+ - !

(2)

uknownada

May. 18, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) It doesn't load.

+ - !

(6)

DedGrimm

Nov. 08, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) That was a good one, except I didn't find any clues for the green buttons and just had to brute force my way through that one.

+ - !

(1)

Deadly_101

Nov. 06, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Is it only me? Or is it that you just cannot find any clues for all those combination locks.. *goes to a different game* -_-

+ - !

(1)

von_Tyrone

Jul. 18, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) I've seen some "puzzle" games that asked for brute-forcing, but this must've been the worst I've seen yet. Where are all the clues for the large number of combination locks? I know there are certain tropes in puzzle games, but most of the tricks seemed to be "because it's in a puzzle game" and not "because this makes any kind of in-universe sense".

+ - !

(1)

versett1

Jun. 28, 2017

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-8)

garukno

Jun. 24, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) i need more MURDER!!!

+ - !

(1)

DubaiBunnies

Jun. 20, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) WOW game

+ - !

(0)

Rosh30

Jun. 08, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) This game had toooooooo......... many puzzles!!!! I have some questions regarding the game. Why did the people who weren't the murderer have bomb, poison and axe?????

+ - !

(4)

DemonWarLord678

Jun. 04, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) I managed to beat this game by bruteforcing not only the code under the piranha but also the light switches and the final guess. This really shouldn't be possible. I didn't even interact with the other guest except the murderer to finish this game.

+ - !

(1)

kHonUgaN

Jun. 03, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Reminds me of the board game Cluedo

+ - !

(1)

jyxwb

May. 31, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) I have a raging clue

+ - !

(1)

oopalmer

May. 30, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Also, just because you find a dead guy with a book in his hand doesn't equal any sort of evidence on where he was murdered. The more logical choice was the music room. You know, the one with a mechanism to hang something?

+ - !

(1)

oopalmer

May. 30, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Speaking of lazy, these are getting worse and worse. We need puzzles... oh just throw a combination lock on 7 things and call it good.

+ - !

(1)

robvw

May. 30, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Not one but two puzzles (three-digit safe and six-switches panel) can be bruteforced. Good thing too, because I eventually ran into the combination for the safe, but still have no clue how to "correctly" solve those switches. Then again, judging by the lack of sensible logic in the rest of the game...

+ - !

(1)

momoisgaming

May. 30, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) hello user are you aware there was ..... A MURDER

+ - !

(4)

mangse

May. 30, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) The whole story doesn't make a lot of sense and the ending just makes you feel like all your other work was for nothing. Shame. Could have been great

+ - !

(1)

FarFromGruntled

May. 28, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) The existence of the book was not a clue - it is possible to carry them from one room to another to read it. What would have been better was if there was some visual clue to where it happened

+ - !

(2)

FarFromGruntled

May. 28, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) So Mr Dawkins was murdered, but no one there knew he was dead? So who called for Sherlock?

+ - !

(5)

ace_bc

May. 24, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Why is the piano tuned to the key of G? I find this very strange.

+ - !

(0)

SodaPopskinski

May. 24, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Why some of these puzzles are a little abstract, this game has charm.

+ - !

(0)

WarLordKev

May. 23, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Good game. I think it had a lot of potential to be something bigger.

+ - !

(0)

Mallybird

May. 17, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Clever way to make us guys the murderer! I just wish the "important pieces of evidence" Had more to do with the game.

+ - !

(1)

cheeselouise

May. 14, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Was there a motive for the murder? Did I just miss it?

+ - !

(1)

semrem

May. 13, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Sherlock seems to be more dangerous than the actual murderer seeing as he's trying to kill everyone

+ - !

(7)

lollolilol

May. 12, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Sherlock is also suspicious, he doesn't cast a shadow too. And he knows of the muder without anyone calling him.

+ - !

(40)

girl007

May. 11, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) I would have preferred Watson going beside Sherlock looking at him obnoxiously because Sherlock's giving everyone a snare. lol

+ - !

(2)

amdfdf

May. 10, 2017

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-8)

Effulgent

May. 10, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Spoiler: Honestly, it never occurred to me that the murderer would have the safe combination - it was just process of elimination since they were the only one who didn't still have a weapon on them

+ - !

(7)

Sir_Poopington

May. 10, 2017

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-17)

chibis223

May. 10, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) If nobody knew he was murdered, why is Sherlock even there??

+ - !

(4)

TheDarkestHour34

May. 09, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Why was there even a murder in the first place, there's not a motive at all... GIVE ME A REASON WHY YOU KILLED THAT MAN

+ - !

(4)

Georgie_Leech

May. 09, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) ...Why did I try to bring down a massive bell right next to someone? Why did I take a chainsaw to a ladder some guy was standing on? Why did I try to cause an allergic reaction? ...Are we entirely certain this isn't just Holmes trying to cover his tracks?

+ - !

(71)

HepiSmajli

May. 09, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) kind of a dumb

+ - !

(3)

Andostre

May. 08, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Holmes sure makes a lot of assumptions this time around.

+ - !

(3)

dauntless

May. 08, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Most common incorrect safe code: 109

+ - !

(7)

Kingkkrool

May. 06, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Bugged for the solution(at least in French version). Tried twice, always blocked when I want to enter the Murder/Weapon/Room. I tried all possibilities and watcher walkthrough just in case, Done button doesn't work.

+ - !

(4)

Developer response from esthetix

We uploaded a fix, thank you for reporting!

DuluT

May. 06, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) I can't help it but i spend a bit time at the piano to play a music. XD

+ - !

(20)

Jeffe77

May. 05, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Colonel Ketchup was framed by the other three.

+ - !

(14)

Mordeckai

May. 05, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) I think the real mystery here is why Miss Bleach doesn't have a shadow.

+ - !

(2)

Trenchcloak

May. 05, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) I had hopes that a replay who result in a different murderer, weapon, and location. Sadly, no.

+ - !

(47)

Meldoreth

May. 05, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Nice, fresh format for a Carmel Games clicker. Like the mystery puzzle at the end, it made it more than just a sequential click plot to solve. Although the solution required a little different observation that I thought at first. Which was good :)

+ - !

(10)

NicolasRei

May. 05, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Easier than most, but enjoyable.

+ - !

(2)

dauntless

May. 05, 2017

Under rating threshold (show) Miss Bleach is suspicious because she doesn't cast a shadow

+ - !

(31)

tigertooth321

May. 05, 2017

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-30)

Gladiatron

May. 05, 2017

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-35)

  • add a comment
  • « First
  • 1 - 47
  • Last »
Developers Players Support YouTube TikTok X (Twitter) LinkedIn
Join the conversation Join Discord
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Code of Conduct
© 2026 Kongregate